Tuesday, July 06, 2010

Afghan War

The war in Afghanistan is turning into a war between Christianity and Islam. Let us see what would happen if all the terrorist activities ceased and Christians and Muslims became the best of friends.

First of all the Palestinian problem will be solved in favor of the Palestinians. Secondly the Kashmir problem will be solved in favor of Pakistan. Thirdly the Chehcen problem will be solved in favor of the Muslims.


Obviously the terrorist activities of the Alqaeda and Taliban are against the interest of the Muslims. Also their cessation would be against the interests of some other parties who are easy to recognize

Saturday, June 12, 2010

The Greatest Achievement of Science

Somebody once asked me what the greatest achievement of science was. I think I replied “moonwalk”, and that was the end of the conversation. But my thoughts did not stop there. The question had a meaning that I had missed. Moonwalk was an achievement of human beings, scientists to be exact. But what had science as an entity done to be adored as we do? After a long time the answer dawned on me and it surprised me. The greatest achievement of science was ‘democracy’.


Until the end of the sixteenth century or perhaps the beginning of the seventeenth century Europeans had no choice but to believe that what the king said was laws. Worldly laws were made only by kings. Laws of a divine nature were made by the top man in the church. Ordinary men could not make laws. But starting with Galileo’s rejection of Aristotelian ideas and the advent of modern science, things changed. There came a procession of laws made by ordinary mortals with no relation to royalty or the church. Newton’s Laws of motion and gravitation, Boyle’s law, Chales’s law, Dalton’s law, Ohm’s law etc. etc. And neither royalty nor the church could challenge or alter these laws.

Once the people of Europe realized that it was possible for them to make laws, the paradigm of politics and sovereignty changed. The people had to create a situation in which they could make the laws of the land as they suited them.

The reason why democracy eludes many nations outside Europe and North America is that people there still believe that lawmaking is the purview of the privileged and not common people. Once they acquire the taste for making laws they will achieve democracy.

Tuesday, June 08, 2010

1984

Way back in the early 1970s I read George Orwell's novel Nineteen Eighty-four and nearly forgot about it when things in Britain didn't change much. Now that I am visiting the United States I am suddenly reminded of the book. There seem to be clear and subtle similarities between the land of 1984 and present day USA, Perhaps I shall read the book again when I return home and write about my observations of this journey.

Sunday, June 06, 2010

Islam for the Perverted

By Naseem Mahnavi
naseem.mahnavi@gmail.com

As were the days of Noah, so will be the coming of the Son of man. For as in those days before the flood they were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, until the day when Noah entered the ark, and they did not know until the flood came and swept them all away, so will be the coming of the Son of man.
Matthew 24: 37-39

Say ye: "We believe in Allah and the revelation given to us and to Ibraheem, Isma`il, Isaac, Jacob and the Tribes and that given to Moosa and Issa and that given to (all) Prophets from their Lord we make no difference between one and another of them and we bow to Allah (in Islam)." (The Qur’an verse 2:136

If Allah so willed He could make you all one people: but He leaves straying whom He pleases and He guides whom He pleases: but ye shall certainly be called to account for all your actions. (The Qur’an verse 16:93)

And the Jews say: The Christians do not follow anything (good) and the Christians say: The Jews do not follow anything (good) while they recite the (same) Book. Even thus say those who have no knowledge, like to what they say; so Allah shall judge between them on the day of resurrection in what they differ. (The Qur’an verse 2:113)

And the Jews will not be pleased with you, nor the Christians until you follow their religion. Say: Surely Allah's guidance: that is the (true) guidance. And if you follow their desires after the knowledge that has come to you, you shall have no guardian from Allah, nor any helper. (The Qur’an verse 2:120)

O you who believe! be careful of (your duty to) Allah with the care which is due to Him, and do not die unless you are Muslims. (The Qur’an verse 3:102)


1. INTRODUCTION

All religions started with the common purpose of uniting and guiding people to a healthy and desirable way of life that would ensure social harmony in this world and peace even after death. They also provided a platform for coordinated thought and regulation of life. Unfortunately, ambitious religious leaders found it convenient to raise points of difference and divide the believers into churches, sects, schisms and temples. In modern times, religious organizations resemble tourist bus services to heaven. Buy a ticket, hop into one and the driver will deliver you to the gates of paradise. The sad part is that there is no insurance or money-back guarantee. Even more disturbing is the thought that if they deliver you to the wrong gates, there is no return or detour.


1.1 Bismillah

Islam literally means accepting a reality, and not surrender in the sense of laying down arms as is commonly mistaken. The meaning of the most frequently used Arabic sentence “Bismillah irrahman irraheem” can be best understood by translating the article “Al” as “the real”. The meaning then becomes “In the name of the real Master, the real beneficent and the really merciful.” That is the beginning of the search for truth.

The Holy Qur’an is the only religious book that states plainly that men and women were created from a single soul (verse 4:1), implying that spiritually they are equal and gives clear-cut instructions about moral and ethical principles. Prophet Muhammad in his last sermon categorically stated that the red man is not superior to the black man and vice versa. Much of mankind ignored these instructions for 1300 odd years after the revelation of the Holy Qur’an until Dr. Christian Barnard of apartheid South Africa unwittingly demonstrated the Qur’anic truth in 1969 by transplanting a woman’s heart in a man’s body that lived for months and trans-racial heart transplants followed. The world has changed considerably since then. Apartheid evaporated from South Africa and women and black people are no longer considered inferior in the Western world. The advancements of science have many indicators to divine truths that seem to be ignored by most educated people.

The Qur’an contains all the essential parts of the old and new Testaments in addition to the unique revelations to Prophet Muhammad. Neither the exact Ten Commandments nor the socio-economic principles that have come to be known as Jewish morality and Christian values, can be found stated directly in either the Old or the New Testaments. They can only be found stated clearly and unambiguously in the Third Testament called the Holy Qur’an. Almost any book of prose or poetry can be interpreted to portray high ideals and moral principles, and the moral values of all religions except Islam are derived from legends and anecdotes. In a most unusual show of magnanimity for a religion, Islam endorses both Christianity and Jewish faith as religions of Divine inspiration and acknowledges both Issa (Jesus) and Moosa (Moses) as Prophets of God and divine predecessors of Prophet Muhammad. The Muslims are awaiting the return of Issa more anxiously than the Christians. The Qur’an goes to the extent of saying in verse 2:62,

“Those who believe (in the Qur'an) and those who follow the Jewish (Scriptures) and the Christians and the Sabians and who believe in Allah and the last day and work righteousness shall have their reward with their Lord; on them shall be no fear nor shall they grieve.”

It is not surprising that the drivers of the Jewish and Christian buses to paradise do not stop at the Qur’an shop on the way.

If one looks back in history, one finds that whereas the words of the Qur'an are constant and unchanging, its understanding has an evolutionary character. In the first phase during the lives of the Prophet and early Caliphs, the mere repetition of the text was enough as the listener knew the language well enough and the intonation would make the meaning quite clear. The cultural or environmental symbolism was also well understood and the references to specific events were only parts of their lives. In the second phase when Islam had spread in most of Arabia and around it where dialects of Arabic were spoken, it had to be presented in writing, with detailed punctuation and a few explanatory notes. In the third phase when Islam had spread far and wide in the world, it was understood by majority of its readers with the help of translations and a few marginal comments. In the fourth phase when it was no longer taught in primary curriculum and its basic concepts had become alien to most of its readers, it was understood with the aid of lengthy explanations and references to Hadith and other books. In the fifth phase, which is still in progress, there has been an attempt to reconcile Qur'anic and scientific knowledge rather than treat them as opposites. It would be such a pity if, while reading the Qur'an, one were to ignore the wealth of knowledge mankind has acquired as a consequence of being inspired by it. Those who think in terms of scientific references can only be convinced about the validity of an idea in scientific terms.

The importance of independent thought and action in Islam was underscored by the Prophet when he insisted that those who went to his mosque must meditate on their own before and after he led them in prayers. Prophet Muhammad was a true democrat. He did not treat his simple followers like a herd of sheep. He treated them as intelligent human beings and trained them so that they could manage their relationship with God by themselves, without dependence on any sort of clergy. Before Islam, religion was something that was administered by a priest and the common man was a captive of the religious establishment. Unfortunately, today many Muslim believers have also become captives of their misguided leaders.

This author’s thinking is based on the assumption that the Universe has been objectively engineered and that there could be a margin of error in God's work. True that God is perfect, but nowhere has He claimed that any of His creations is absolutely as intended. The imperfection of His creations by no means diminishes His own greatness. It is possible that God intended the Earth to be inclined at a quarter of a right angle to its orbital plane, but actually it turned out to be 23.5 degrees i.e. one degree more, or that the year was intended to be exactly 360 days and not 365 and a quarter as it actually is. Similarly, evil exists not because it was intended by God but as a consequence of the imperfections of the creations; and God has set in motion a process of evolution and guidance for the rectification of these defects and for improvement in the quality of His creations. All the tangible knowledge of physics, Chemistry, Biology, Electronics, Mechanics and much of Mathematics that is or will ever be written in books is already at work in the human body. Man is not discovering Science, but only learning to express what is already inherent in him. The rest is speculation.

This book has been written neither to gain accolades from Islamic scholars nor to tease them. The intended readership of this book consists of Muslims who are well versed in secular studies, but fail to find interest in Islamic literature. If a man does fear or believe in God and does not admire Muhammad (PBUH), his interest can only be aroused by showing him that the Qur’an also deals in the subject that constitutes his passion for knowledge. A scientist would read the Qur’an only if convinced that it contains science, which it certainly does. The same is true of other secular professions such as medicine, economics, law, psychology, sociology etc. It is also meant for Non-Muslims who would like to know the essence of Islam without giving up their prejudices in the first place. As for the perverted, they may get interested in Islam after reading this book, but can not go any further astray than they already are.

In the following pages, there are a number of essays that were inspired by religious study, but also include related secular knowledge that supplements the religious ideas. The technological bias in the thinking is the inevitable result of this author’s own professional passion. Even my belief in God is partly owed to the fact that no one has reported finding a piece of naturally occurring quartz or grain of sand with a functional digital logic circuit formed by random mutations.


1.2. The Need for Religion

There are two basic types of religion. The first is the divine type that concerns itself with all aspects of life including every thing from the creation of the universe to what happens after one dies. Islam, Christianity, Jewish faith and Vedantic Hinduism are the most common examples of divine religion. The second is the social type that concerns mainly with how one conducts one self in the world and with respect to other living beings. Examples of the social type are Buddhism, Jainism, Taoism, Confucianism, Sikhism etc.

All divine religious thought starts from one basic thesis that can be stated as follows:

For any new action to take place anywhere in the universe, a command must be generated somewhere by someone. Therefore, all efforts to achieve physical results should also be complemented with prayers to a Command-generator for the issuance of necessary commands to ensure that the efforts produce the desired results.

Not only a modern day computer programmer would quickly endorse the idea of the necessity of command for action, but it seems that even the prehistoric philosophers were convinced that in order to function stably within life sustaining limits, the world requires a supervisory system. Consequently, numerous models of the probable supervisory system were put forward in different parts of the world and came to be known as religions. The Greeks had a god for everything. Indian religious literature speaks of a million great souls (Mahan atman) who reside in the Himalayas and control every thing that happens in the world. Biblical and Islamic traditions even give names of angels who are assigned the management of various worldly functions such as communication, arranging rains and crops, and taking lives etc. The mathematical concept of God is one of a universal origin. One simple example is the origin of a graph where the coordinate axes intersect. All the processes and equations exist at this point, but the values of all the variables and functions are zero. At the same time, no point in the system can be defined without reference to the origin. Hence the frequent references to God (Insha Allah) by those with a strong sense of religion.

However, in most communities, closed institutions were formed which claimed to have access to the supervisory system and began to make demands on their respective communities that would place the former in an unreasonably comfortable and dominant position in relation to other fellow beings in return for solving their problems by communicating with the supervisory system. As time passed, it became obvious that many, or perhaps most, of these institutions were nothing more than facades to extort undue benefits, and their `miracles' were merely tricks and sleight of hand. On the other hand, the seemingly genuine ones were so tyrannically choosy in allowing new aspirants to join their circles of study, or the initiation rites and initial courses were so atrociously discouraging that very few would have the patience to pursue the discipline for long. So, failing to break the closely guarded circles, the more intelligent and resourceful group (mainly in Europe) decided to find its own access to the universal supervisory system by identifying and tapping into its components or subsystems through the conduit of scientific investigation. Soon the scientific institution, by virtue of its superior ability to heal and comfort, itself became a power axis and conflict between the two became inevitable. Before long, the antagonism grew to such a large extent that the two contenders began to needlessly deny the basis of existence of each other. The result was that the development of both was hindered and, perhaps, even disoriented. An interesting account of confrontations between the seekers of knowledge and policy makers of faith can be found in Hoodbhoy's "Muslims and Science". The modern educated man's ability to believe only selected parts of his own knowledge is indeed an achievement in the area of self-control which far exceeds the ancient mystic's ability to believe in the unknown.

Once we accept the existence of a supervisory system for the Universe and that things happen in this world according to a basic plan, it is possible to develop a coherent scenario spanning the past and future of life on Earth. Almost all religions agree that before the emergence of plant-animal life, the earth was dominated by some sort of spiritual life forms that did not possess physical form in spite of great knowledge, cognitive powers and ability to maneuver matter and energy. Their creator, leader and master is called God. They designed and developed plant and then animal species through a process of controlled organic evolution that culminated in the domination of the Earth by civilized mankind who think that they possess even greater physical strength and ability than their originators. Whether or not that spiritual race continues to pursue the creative process, we do not know as they are beyond our perception. However, the latest developments in genetics indicating that the unique and extremely complex configuration of millions of atoms in the genes in each cell of an animals body multiplies billions of times with exact precision, points to the possibility that there must be some sort of a code prevalent all over the world that motivates and controls the process. Taking into account the fact that all living organisms need exposure to cosmic radiation for growth one wonders if the vital code is contained in some frequency band of the cosmic radiation which is intentionally transmitted from a remote source in the universe. The idea is further reinforced by the fact that there are maria only on that side of the moon that faces the earth, but the other side is quite plain; and the maria so closely resemble reflective dishes that could concentrate many thousand times a signal coming from deep space and focus it onto the earth as a small area scanning spotlight. Anyone hit by the focused beam would acquire the latest operating system for the genome or new utilities that would give him or her apparently supernatural abilities.

God is said to have breathed His Spirit into man, and created a potential creator like Himself, albeit of much lower stature than Himself. True to the task, man has created an entire world of inorganic life consisting of ingenious machinery and industrial plants for which human beings are equivalent to soul. Human civilizations have been working over the past five millennia or so and developed a new life-form in the shape of stationary and mobile machinery that possess even greater physical strength and ability. When the wheel was first invented, man used to push or pull a cart; now a man sits unnoticed in gigantic mobile mechanical devices that perform extraordinary feats. Man has produced mechanical creatures that work in conjunction with man to produce forces, speeds and displacements far in excess of anything that any animal can achieve. With the rapid development of computerized robots, a time may come when the world may appear to be entirely dominated by mechanical life with human beings invisible in the background controlling their destiny. Perhaps Avicena’s prediction that man could reach angelic reason has come true.

It seems that there has been a progression whereby spiritual life created organic life which, in its turn, fashioned inorganic life. The inorganic life system consists of all electric or engine powered machines, equipment and vehicles that move and communicate, and whose numbers and types are constantly growing although they do not produce babies, fruit or seeds. They would die out if we humans stopped caring for and supporting them. Today, it is so easy to compare a human being and his or her soul with an automobile and its driver, but it is interesting that the idea originated thousands of years ago when the analogy did not exist.

Scientific thought relies on the premise that actions are the effects of direct causes that can be manipulated independently by human beings without any spiritual assistance. Whether the human desire to achieve a result could invoke the spiritual command for the desired effect is not a measurable phenomenon and therefore ignored by Science. The mechanism of the cognitive process and inspiration are separated from physical sciences and identified as psychology. However, over the past few centuries scientists have compiled a great amount of knowledge and built a working model of the universe by observing causes and effects and analyzing them. Modern life is so dependent on the exploits of science that it seems absurd to question the validity of the scientific approach. A thousand years ago it would have been sufficient to explain an abnormal occurrence or legend as God’s will. But today we know so much about the ways in which God’s will is exercised that unless one can suggest a feasible mechanism by which the event might take place, the validity of the statement would be unacceptable to the educated mind. Yet, it is impossible to ignore an idea in whose favor more than half the world’s population has cast its vote. There is no doubt that for its own functioning, Science has to depend on mathematical relationships that exist since time unknown and universal constants whose values were fixed by the eternal Cause that can not be observed or measured.

In modern times there exists a secular school of thought. The secular thinker may be totally ignorant of science, and may even practice some religion whether or not he has studied it, but he is opposed to any role of religion except as one of many tolerable personal vices. Secularism seems to have arisen out of protest against the exploitation of the sentiments of honest believers and the occasional show of intolerance and violence by the more faithful, and portrays a fundamental difference in attitudes. Whereas religion insists that human social conduct should be based on a sense of moral duty, secularism believes in the supremacy of self-made law and assertion of rights. However, the universal charter of human rights prepared by the UNO is hardly a match for the eternal charter of human duties embodied in the Qur'an -- the culmination of human and divine religious thought. In the secular system rights imply duties, but in the religious system duties generate rights, which is a more positive way of ensuring equity and harmony. In a religious system one tries to acquire implements that would help to discharge one's duties and please others; in a secular system one tries to amass possessions that reinforce one's confidence and help in asserting one's rights by intimidating others. In some communities a compromise has been reached so that most of the strong and affluent citizens are only concerned with asserting their rights and making large profits, but they do not interfere with the activities of a religious group that considers its duty to help the weak and poor to survive. There are also those who assist others in asserting their rights for a price or share in their fortunes. There seems no reason why modern state management techniques can not be reconciled with religious doctrine and vice versa.

Sunday, May 23, 2010

The Swiss Cases

Sometime during the prime-ministerial reign of Benazir Bhutto, bank accounts were opened in her and her husband’s name in Switzerland and it is suspected that laundered money was transferred in them. It seems very unlikely that the prime minister herself would have performed any illegal acts. However, the possibility that her personal business/financial managers might have been involved in unlawful activities without her knowledge can not be ignored. If so, those faceless men have brought disgrace to both Benazir and the Pakistani nation and they must not be spared. The Swiss cases must be reopened and the men and women who conspired to use the name of respectable Pakistanis to achieve their own foul ends must be given exemplary punishment and the name of Benazir Bhutto must be cleared.

I fully endorse the wisdom of the Supreme Court of Pakistan to reopen the Swiss cases and appeal to the government of Pakistan to act on the verdict without wasting time-- in greater national interest.

Friday, March 12, 2010

More Definitions-2

Cinema = Illusion of motion of objects by sequential display of images


Divorce = Dissolution of marriage frequently as a result of both spouses trying to exploit the other's weaknesses

Drone attack = Cowardly part of war of terror

Hell = Nightmares in eternal sleep

Horrorism = American policy of subduing military and political opponents by creating horror. Examples are Germany and Japan where they succeeded and Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan where they failed.

Natural Selection = Diminution of vulnerability beyond extinction threshold

Paradise = Sweet dreams in eternal sleep

TV = Substitution of mind and soul with sound and picture

Vikingism = Growing intellectual distortion in Northern Europe

Sunday, February 14, 2010

Who is Supreme?

Once again there is a confrontation between the presidency and the judiciary in Pakistan. The president has refused to accept the recommendations of the chief justice and notified judicial appointments at his discretion.


No matter what legal and constitutional experts say, the basic issue is:

Should individuals who are facing trial for criminal offences decide or even participate in the appointment of superior court judges?

The obvious answer is ‘NO’. So, the incumbent president, law minister and a host of other ministers should be barred from the exercise.

But the constitution requires that the appointments be issued by the president, and this can only happen if there is a new president.

The wise solution is that the president and all governors, ministers, advisors and ambassadors who are ‘subjudice’ should resign and should be replaced, after which the judiciary should respect the decisions of the government.

Mr. Zardari has already brought enough disrepute to the presidency of Pakistan and he should not add to his sins. Let us hope that he will not create a situation in which the civil servants will refuse to obey ministerial orders and friendly countries would declare our ambassadors persona non grata. If the impasse continues, there will have to be midterm elections which the opposition parties would sweep and then impeach him. The procedure has already been perfected by his own party.

Wednesday, January 06, 2010

Row after NRO

Last night I watched Dr. Pirzada’s interview of Advocate Asma Jahangir regarding her article in the Dawn of 19th December, 2009 on the Supreme Court’s short judgment on NRO.


It was gratifying to note that most of her views were similar to my own opinions as already recorded in my blogs (Ideas for a New Millennium, URL: www. naseemmahnavi.blogspot.com). However on some points she demonstrated the same naiveté as is characteristic of our intellectuals and I feel compelled to put the record straight.

Somehow Ms Jahangir failed to realize that the present judicial setup in Pakistan is the only one in the world put in place by “people power” which places some unique burdens on it. Their judgments have to reflect popular sentiment whether or not the relevant definitive legislation which is supposed to reflect popular sentiment does so due to incompleteness or inadequacy or mischief.

Ms Jahangir is still talking of the three pillars of state which is a concept far left behind. In the modern day reality state and sovereign do not exist. Countries are governed by a collective national leadership composed of political, economic, military, educational, creative, productive etc segments comprising of legitimate achievers in their own fields. The political segment is formed by conforming noncontroversial leaders who migrate from other segments to form a body that directs public opinion and national affairs.

These various segments of national leadership are supposed to carryout internal ethical audits through closed door accountability and mutual criticism. As a distinguished member of the judicial segment of the national leadership Ms Jahangir has a right and duty to review the actions of her peers. But it would have been better if she had chosen a less populist or less vulgar forum such as the Bar council to air her view and chastised the erring judges out of public view. The way she has acted to wash judicial dirty linen in the public some television joker might call her a lousy “dhoban.” Not that it would diminish her achievements.

The process of national catharsis that seems to have started by default on the erasure of the NRO should continue and every sensible person who does not have skeletons in his or her closets should support it. It is a pity that Dr. Pirzada failed to ask the lady whom she would support if there was another confrontation between the judiciary and the presidency. My choice is obvious.

Monday, December 07, 2009

NRO

The full bench of the Supreme Court of Pakistan is to start hearing the cases against the infamous NRO from 7th December, 2009. So this is the last chance of commenting on it.

As a result of the recent disclosures about NRO the PPP has emerged as a party of pretty women and ugly men, while the MQM has become “mera qasoor maaf”.

One of the obvious shortcomings of the non-law NRO is that it does not define the terms used in it. It speaks of the withdrawal of “political cases”, on the basis of which criminal and corruption cases have been withdrawn. If political is interpreted as criminal or corrupt then politics becomes tantamount to crime and corruption, a notion that must be universally condemned.

The most significant action under the NRO was the withdrawal of the Cotecna kick-back case from the Swiss courts. The fact is that Cotecna had bribed the government functionaries heavily to win a contract for assessing customs duty on imports at Pakistani ports. They used this position to make a list of the cosigners of those sensitive and defense related shipments which were exempted by government order from being examined by Cotecna; and sold it to the foreign agencies that had helped it in obtaining the contract. From these lists they were able to establish the identity of the Kahuta supply network which provided precision equipment and instrumentation for the uranium gas centrifuges being built there. Extremist Christian elements dubbed the Kahuta supply network, a legitimate business proposition, as the Khan nuclear proliferation network.

It is a pity that the brilliant Pakistani scientists who had made a technological breakthrough in which most western countries had failed, instead of being internationally acclaimed and rewarded were treated as wanted criminals.

In any case, the withdrawal of the case against Cotecna was abetment of international crime and treason against Pakistan. The NRO must be declared null and void ab initio and at least the Cotecna case must be reopened and the government of Pakistan should claim damages of at least ten billion dollars against Cotecna.

Monday, November 02, 2009

More Taxes?

Mr. Shaukat Treen the financial advisor to GOP keeps saying that the tax to GDP ratio in Pakistan is only 9-10% which is too low and should be increased. He seems to forget that agriculture contributes 25% of Pakistan's GDP and agricultural income is not taxed. So the actual Tax/GDP ratio of taxed GDP is more like 12-14% which is higher than China, India, Bangladesh, Russia and perhaps even USA. Any further increase in the taxation of the industrial and services sectors would be simply criminal and counterproductive. After all Mr. Tareen is a highly respectd Banker but hardly an economist (which I am not either, but I try to get my sums right). Tax the agricultural income and all of Pakistan's economic woes will disappear. We might even become able to say "get lost" to Kerry-Lugar circus.


It is worth mentioning here that the actual government expenditure in Pakistan is over 20% of GDP including income from the giant state owned enterprizes; but offers none of the benefits enjoyed by the citizens of European countries with similar state expenditure ratio.

The reason why agricultural income is not taxed in Pakistan is that most of it goes into the pockets of a few dozen landlord families easily identified as Chaudhrys, Makhdooms, Sardars, Maliks and Pirs. Add to them the decendants of the knights and title holders of the British empire such as Bhuttos. Unfortunately for the peolple of Pakistan, these families also dominate the political scene and abort any initiative to tax agricultural income by conniving together and with military rulers.

Everywhere in the world the agricultural sector feeds the nation, but in Pakistan it fleeces and starves the nation with impunity.